Amigo Loans warned on Monday that it was struggling to deal with a rising tide of customer complaints, forcing it to delay its full-year results and set aside further cash to deal with the backlog.
Shares in the company dropped by 25 per cent to a fresh record low after the announcement, bringing its market capitalisation to just £35m — less than the amount it expects to spend remedying the complaints.
Last month the subprime lender made an agreement with the Financial Conduct Authority requiring it to respond to around 9,000 customer complaints by the end of this week. On Monday, however, Amigo reported a “substantial increase in the rate of complaints” and said it was in discussions with the regulator to extend its agreement.
Amigo dominates the market for guarantor loans, providing cash to people with weak credit histories if they have friends or family willing to step in if they fail to repay. The FCA is investigating whether its approach to checking if customers can afford to repay their loans since 2018 has been compliant with UK lending regulations.
The investigation began after Amigo founder James Benamor accused the company’s board of recklessly extending new loans under the same terms that had led to complaints about “irresponsible lending” in the past.
Mr Benamor’s battle with Amigo’s new management culminated in an unsuccessful attempt by him to depose the entire board of directors last week. The 43-year-old said in response that he would sell his 61 per cent stake in the company.
Amigo put itself up for sale earlier this year and held discussions with one unnamed company about a potential £100m deal, but the buyer pulled out this month, blaming the “current market environment”.
John Cronin, analyst at Goodbody, said the recent increase in complaints was likely driven by professional claims management companies. “While there are options to explore in reaching some form of resolution or closure with the regulator on complaints, there is no end in sight on the issue at present,” he said.
Amigo said it would “continue to assess each complaint on a case-by-case basis to ensure fair outcomes for our customers”, but said there would be a “material” cost on top of the £35m it announced for dealing with the initial backlog. The company said it would publish its full-year results by July 23, compared with its earlier aim of reporting by the end of June.
Shares in Amigo, which listed at 275p each just two years ago, have fallen 89 per cent since the start of this year, to 7p per share.